Anti-Corruption Layer

Definition

The Anti-Corruption Layer (ACL) isolates the internal domain model from external models (third-party APIs, SDKs, legacy formats). A translation layer converts external DTOs into Granit domain types, preventing foreign concepts from “polluting” the framework core.

Diagram

flowchart LR
    subgraph External["External services"]
        KC["Keycloak Admin API"]
        S3["AWS S3 SDK"]
        BR["Brevo API"]
        FCM["Firebase FCM"]
        MK["MailKit / SMTP"]
    end

    subgraph ACL["Anti-Corruption Layer"]
        KC_DTO["KeycloakUserRepresentation"]
        KC_MAP["ToIdentityUser()"]
        S3_ADP["S3BlobClient"]
        BR_ADP["BrevoNotificationProvider"]
        FCM_ADP["GoogleFcmMobilePushSender"]
        MK_ADP["MailKitEmailSender"]
    end

    subgraph Domain["Granit domain model"]
        IU["IdentityUser"]
        BD["BlobDescriptor"]
        EM["EmailMessage"]
        PM["MobilePushMessage"]
    end

    KC --> KC_DTO --> KC_MAP --> IU
    S3 --> S3_ADP --> BD
    BR --> BR_ADP --> EM
    FCM --> FCM_ADP --> PM
    MK --> MK_ADP --> EM

    style External fill:#fef0f0,stroke:#c44e4e
    style ACL fill:#fef3e0,stroke:#e8a317
    style Domain fill:#e8fde8,stroke:#2d8a4e

Implementation in Granit

Keycloak — the most comprehensive case

Granit.Identity.Keycloak is the framework’s canonical ACL. Keycloak responses are deserialized into internal DTOs (KeycloakUserRepresentation, KeycloakSessionRepresentation, etc.) then converted to domain models via private static methods:

// External DTO (internal, never exposed)
internal sealed record KeycloakUserRepresentation(
    [property: JsonPropertyName("id")] string Id,
    [property: JsonPropertyName("username")] string Username,
    [property: JsonPropertyName("email")] string? Email,
    // ...
);

// Conversion to domain model
private static IdentityUser ToIdentityUser(KeycloakUserRepresentation user) =>
    new(user.Id, user.Username, user.Email, user.FirstName, user.LastName,
        user.Enabled, FlattenAttributes(user.Attributes));

Specifics:

• FlattenAttributes() — converts Keycloak Dictionary(string, List(string)) to Granit Dictionary(string, string) (multi-value attributes to single value)
• ToIdentitySession() — converts Unix timestamps (milliseconds) to DateTimeOffset
• ToIdentityGroup() — recursive mapping for subgroups

Claims transformation (JWT)

KeycloakClaimsTransformation and EntraIdClaimsTransformation extract roles from proprietary JSON structures (realm_access.roles, resource_access.{client}.roles) and convert them to standard .NET ClaimTypes.Role claims.

ACL inventory in Granit

External service	ACL package	External DTO to internal model
Keycloak Admin API	Granit.Identity.Keycloak	KeycloakUserRepresentation to IdentityUser
Keycloak JWT	Granit.Authentication.Keycloak	JSON realm_access to ClaimTypes.Role
Entra ID JWT	Granit.Authentication.EntraId	JSON roles (v1.0/v2.0) to ClaimTypes.Role
AWS S3 SDK	Granit.BlobStorage.S3	GetPreSignedUrlRequest from BlobUploadRequest
MailKit SMTP	Granit.Notifications.Email.Smtp	MimeMessage from EmailMessage
Brevo API	Granit.Notifications.Brevo	JSON payload from EmailMessage / SmsMessage / WhatsAppMessage
Firebase FCM	Granit.Notifications.MobilePush.GoogleFcm	FcmPayload from MobilePushMessage
ImageMagick	Granit.Imaging.MagickNet	MagickFormat to/from ImageFormat (bidirectional)
Import systems	Granit.DataExchange.EntityFrameworkCore	External ID (Odoo __export__) to internal Entity ID

Architectural principles

1. External DTOs are internal — never exposed outside the adapter package
2. Conversion methods are private static — isolated from the rest of the code
3. Error transformation — external errors are parsed and encapsulated in domain exceptions
4. Graceful degradation — reads log a warning and return null; writes propagate the exception
5. [ExcludeFromCodeCoverage] — on adapters requiring a live service (S3, SMTP)

Reference files

File	Role
src/Granit.Identity.Keycloak/Internal/KeycloakIdentityProvider.cs	Primary ACL (9 conversion methods)
src/Granit.Identity.Keycloak/Internal/KeycloakUserRepresentation.cs	Keycloak external DTO
src/Granit.Authentication.Keycloak/Authentication/KeycloakClaimsTransformation.cs	JWT claims to Role
src/Granit.BlobStorage.S3/Internal/S3BlobClient.cs	S3 adapter
src/Granit.Notifications.Email.Smtp/Internal/MailKitEmailSender.cs	SMTP adapter
src/Granit.Notifications.Brevo/Internal/BrevoNotificationProvider.cs	Multi-channel Brevo
src/Granit.Notifications.MobilePush.GoogleFcm/Internal/GoogleFcmMobilePushSender.cs	FCM adapter
src/Granit.Imaging.MagickNet/Internal/MagickFormatMapper.cs	Image format mapping

Rationale

Problem	ACL solution
Keycloak models in the domain = tight coupling	internal DTOs + static conversion
Keycloak API change = impact across the entire codebase	Only the adapter changes, the domain remains stable
JWT claims format differs between Keycloak and Entra ID	Dedicated transformations, unified ClaimTypes.Role model
Multi-value Keycloak attributes vs single-value Granit	FlattenAttributes() in the ACL
Unix timestamps (ms) in Keycloak vs DateTimeOffset in .NET	Conversion in ToIdentitySession()

Usage example

// The endpoint only knows the IdentityUser domain model,
// never the Keycloak DTOs

private static async Task<Results<Ok<IdentityUser>, NotFound>> GetUserAsync(
    string userId,
    IIdentityProvider identityProvider,
    CancellationToken cancellationToken)
{
    // IIdentityProvider is implemented by KeycloakIdentityProvider
    // which does: API call > KeycloakUserRepresentation > ToIdentityUser()
    IdentityUser? user = await identityProvider
        .FindByIdAsync(userId, cancellationToken)
        .ConfigureAwait(false);

    return user is not null
        ? TypedResults.Ok(user)
        : TypedResults.NotFound();
}

Further reading

• Anti-Corruption Layer — Microsoft Cloud Design Patterns